West Village
Get directions | 259 W 4th St, New York, NY 10014
Hours | Sunday 10am-11pm, Monday 12pm-11pm, Tuesday 12pm-11pm, Wednesday 12pm-11pm, Thursday 12pm-11:30pm, Friday 12pm-, Saturday 10am-
As I was going through and re-writing our review for Extra Virgin from five years ago, something really stood out to me. For all we talk about in terms of our oldest reviews needing updating, there are some restaurants that simply don’t change. Extra Virgin is one of them. This place is still exactly the same as it was five years ago – the food is still really good, it’s still ideally suited for Date Night, and we’d still come here and dine solo at the bar any night of the week. I honestly could have left the original 2009 review for this place completely intact and simply changed the date, and everything would still be relevant to you today. Ok, maybe not that Adam Sandler reference I made, but definitely everything else.
I think what we appreciate most about Extra Virgin is its consistency. Is this the best restaurant in the West Village? No, it isn’t. Do they use too much butter in many of the dishes? If you believe such a thing is possible, then probably. But there’s something nice about knowing what you’re going to get when you walk into a place, even if you haven’t been there in two years. I know that when I walk into Extra Virgin on any given night that it will be packed but that I can likely find a seat at the bar, and that whatever I decide to eat, I’m going to enjoy it. Consistency is a beautiful thing.
Speaking of consistency, this restaurant still ranks near the top of our list for any situation in which you’re planning to have dinner with a someone that you’d like to do it with. And by ‘it’ I mean eat some quality fish and talk about what books you both like.
What did you think I meant?
(212) 691-9359
evrestaurant@gmail.com
https://www.instagram.com/extravirginnyc/?hl=en
Corn Tortilla Soup
shredded chicken, corn, avocado, queso fresco, cilantro
CLASSICS
$25
MON – BAKED LASAGNA
meat sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, fontina, parmesan, spinach
$27
TUES – COQ AU VIN
burgundy braised chicken, boulangere potatoes, bacon, mushrooms
$28
WED – LEMON SOLE ALMONDINE
cauliflower gratin, haricot verts, lemon butter
$23
THURS – BOURBON GLAZED MEAT LOAF
spinach, whipped potatoes, cranberry relish, mushroom gravy
$29
FRI – PAELLA WITH SAFFRON RICE
snapper, calamari, mussels, shrimp, clams, chickpeas, spicy tomato broth
$33
SAT – “7 HOUR BRAISED” BARBEQUE LAMB SHANK
sweet corn risotto, spinach, corn salsa, crispy onions, rosemary
$28
SUN – SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
shaved parmesan, roasted garlic flat bread
SALADS
$17
EXTRA VIRGIN SALAD (GF)
baby arugula, cucumber, tomato, red onion, chianti vinegar
$19
ROASTED ARTICHOKE PARMESAN
poached egg, pancetta, hollandaise
$18
PISTACHIO CRUSTED GOAT CHEESE SALAD
roasted beets, endive, watercress, granny smith apple vinaigrette
$18
CHOPPED WINTER KALE & POMEGRANATE SALAD
baby kale, shaved brussel sprouts, red onion, radish, grape tomatoes, crumbled feta cheese, honey lime cranberry vinaigrette, roasted chick peas, candied walnuts
ADD TO ANY SALAD
chicken 11 / shrimp 13 / salmon 15
STARTERS
$14
ROASTED BUTTERNUT SQUASH SOUP
glazed apples, pomegranate, creme fraiche & vanilla oil
$20
AHI TUNA TARTAR
avocado purée, mango salsa, pickled cucumbers, wasabi vinaigrette
$20
FRITTO MISTO
calamari, rock shrimp, clams, zucchini, spiced tomato sauce
$18
LOBSTER TACOS
pineapple habanero salsa, lime fennel slaw, avocado, chili aioli, pickled onions
$15
FRIED BUFFALO MOZZARELLA
arugula, grilled vine ripened tomatoes, basil, tomato marmalade, balsamic vinaigrette
$19
PROSCIUTTO WRAPPED SEA SCALLOPS
cauliflower purée, red and green grape salad, warm porcini dressing
$20
CHARDONNAY STEAMED MUSSELS
fennel, roasted garlic, shallots, lemon confit, tarragon
PASTA
$29
RIGATONI BOLOGNESE
classic meat sauce, shaved parmesan
$27
BUTTERNUT SQUASH RAVIOLI
brown butter mascarpone sauce, sage, pecorino, toasted pecans
$28
TRUFFLE PARMESAN FUSILLI (GF)
fusilli with a black truffle parmesan broth, sweet potatoes, white asparagus, wild mushrooms, slow roasted tomatoes and sheep’s milk ricotta
SEAFOOD & MEAT
$32
GRILLED ATLANTIC SALMON (GF)
truffle whipped potatoes, grilled asparagus, warm golden tomato and lobster vinaigrette
$36
LEMON CRUSTED CHILEAN SEA BASS
with fennel potato purée, crispy artichokes, salsa verde, avocado purée
$29
PAN SEARED BRANZINO
avocado and rock shrimp salsa, sugar snow pea salad, warm curry vinaigrette
$30
SIMPLY GRILLED MAHI MAHI (Gf)
fresh herbs, tomato carpaccio, arugula, extra virgin olive oil
$30
MUSHROOM CRUSTED VIRGIN CHICKEN
sweet pea risotto, cipollini onions, truffle broth
$31
HANGER STEAK AU POIVRE
balsamic glazed onions, fries, béarnaise
$35
RED WINE BRAISED SHORT RIBS
horseradish whipped potatoes, root vegetables, pearl onions, red wine sauce
BURGERS
$21
GRILLED 8oz SIRLOIN BURGER
with fries or salad; add cheese , bacon 2.00/ea, avocado 5.00
$22
TRUFFLED MUSHROOM ASPARAGUS TURKEY BURGER
porcini aioli, with fries or salad; add cheese, bacon 2.00/ea, avocado 5.00
SIDES
$13
Parmesan Roasted Cauliflower With Toasted Garlic
$13
Fries With Gorgonzola Fondue
$13
Truffle Mac And Cheese Tart
$13
Grilled Asparagus
$13
Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Caramelized Apples And Pancetta
$13
Extra Virgin Whipped Potatoes
$13
Truffle Whipped Potatoes
LUNCH THURSDAY & FRIDAY FROM 11AM TO 4PM
STARTERS
$14
ROASTED BUTTERNUT SQUASH SOUP
Glazed apples, pomegranate, creme fraiche & vanilla oil
$20
AHI TUNA TARTAR
avocado purée, mango salsa, pickled cucumbers, wasabi vinaigrette
$22
CHARDONNAY STEAMED MUSSLES
fennel, roasted garlic, shallots, lemon confit, tarragon
$20
FRITTO MISTO
calamari, rock shrimp, clams, zucchini, spiced tomato sauce
$18
LOBSTER TACOS
pineapple habanero salsa, lime fennel slaw, avocado, chili aioli, pickled onions
$19
PROSCIUTTO WRAPPED SEA SCALLOPS
cauliflower purée, red and green grape salad, warm porcini dressing
$17
EXTRA VIRGIN SALAD (GF)
baby arugula, cucumber, tomato, red onion, avocado, chianti vinegar
$18
PISTACHIO CRUSTED GOAT CHEESE SALAD
roasted beets, endive, watercress, granny smith apple vinaigrette
$18
CHOPPED WINTER KALE & POMEGRANATE SALAD
baby kale, shaved brussel sprouts, red onion, radish, grape tomatoes, crumbled feta cheese, honey lime cranberry vinaigrette, roasted chick peas, candied walnuts
ADD TO ANY SALAD
chicken 11 / shrimp 13 / salmon 15
MAIN
$19
EGGS BENEDICT
smoked bacon, english muffin, with fries or salad
sub smoked salmon $21
$22
MEDITERRANEAN AVOCADO TOAST AND EGGS
poached eggs, feta, black olive, cucumber, red onion, tomato marmalade, hollandaise sauce
$16
BACON EGG & CHEESE ON ENGLISH MUFFIN (GF)
smoked bacon, egg, choice of cheese, with fries or salad
$19
VEGETARIAN OMELETTE (GF)
eggs, asparagus, mushrooms, with fries or salad
$20
THE GARCIA OMELETTE (GF)
roasted peppers & onion, serrano chili, chorizo, jack cheese, ranchero sauce, with fries or salad
$21
BANANA FRENCH TOAST
caramelized bananas, whipped mascarpone
$21
GRILLED 8oz SIRLOIN BURGER
with fries or salad; add cheese, bacon 2.00/ea avocado 5.00
$19
TAHINI LIME MARINATED CHICKEN SANDWICH
cucumber, tomato, red onion, black olive aioli, tzatziki, grilled bread with fries or salad
$22
TRUFFLED MUSHROOM ASPARAGUS TURKEY BURGER
porcini aioli, with fries or salad; add cheese, bacon 2.00/ea avocado 5.00
$29
RIGATONI BOLOGNESE
classic meat sauce, shaved parmesan
$28
TRUFFLE PARMESAN FUSILLI (GF)
fusilli with a black truffle parmesan broth, sweet potatoes, white asparagus, wild mushrooms, slow roasted tomatoes and sheep’s milk ricotta
$27
BUTTERNUT SQUASH RAVIOLI
brown butter mascarpone sauce, sage, pecorino, toasted pecans
$31
GRILLED ATLANTIC SALMON (GF)
truffle whipped potatoes, grilled asparagus, warm golden tomato and lobster vinaigrette
$31
HANGER STEAK AU POIVRE
balsamic glazed onions, fries, béarnaise
SIDES
$13
Parmesan Roasted Cauliflower With Toasted Garlic
$13
Fries With Gorgonzola Fondue
$13
Truffle Mac And Cheese Tart
$13
Grilled Asparagus
$13
Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Caramelized Apples And Pancetta
$13
Extra Virgin Whipped Potatoes
$13
Sautéed Spinach With Garlic
$13
Truffle Whipped Potatoes
BRUNCH WEEKENDS FROM 11AM TO 4PM
SPECIAL
$19
MONTE CRISTO
honey ham, brie, smoked turkey, gruyere, grain mustard, toasted in creme brulee batter, cranberry pomegranite relish with fries or salad
EGGS & GRANOLA
$15
BACON EGG & CHEESE ON ENGLISH MUFFIN
smoked bacon, egg, choice of cheese, with fries or salad
$21
BANANA FRENCH TOAST
caramelized bananas, whipped mascarpone
$15
BUTTERMILK OATMEAL NUT PANCAKES
warm berry compote
$19
VEGETARIAN OMELETTE (GF)
eggs, asparagus, mushrooms, swiss; choice of fries or salad
$19
EGGS BENEDICT
smoked bacon, english muffin, with fries or salad
sub smoked salmon $21
$22
MEDITERRANEAN AVOCADO TOAST AND EGGS
poached eggs, feta, black olive, cucumber, red onion, tomato marmalade, hollandaise sauce
$20
THE GARCIA OMELETTE (GF)
roasted peppers & onion, serrano chili, chorizo, jack cheese, ranchero sauce, with fries or salad
$15
GRANOLA FRUIT YOGURT (GF)
yogurt, fresh berries, orange blossom honey
$18
VIRGIN FRITTATA (GF)
goat cheese, roasted tomato, arugula, basil pesto
$18
BASQUE SCRAMBLE (GF)
pereronata, creamy polenta, salsa verde, avocado puree, chorizo
$20
HUEVOS RANCHEROS (GF)
crispy corn tortilla, eggs sunny side up, black beans, pico de gallo, avocado, quest fresco
SALADS
$17
EXTRA VIRGIN SALAD (GF)
baby arugula, cucumber, tomato, red onion, avocado, chianti vinegar
$18
PISTACHIO CRUSTED GOAT CHEESE SALAD
roasted beets, endive, watercress, granny smith apple vinaigrette
$18
CHOPPED WINTER KALE & POMEGRANATE SALAD
baby kale, shaved brussel sprouts, red onion, radish, grape tomatoes, crumbled feta cheese, honey lime cranberry vinaigrette, roasted chick peas, candied walnuts
$24
SHRIMP COBB SALAD
marinated shrimp, avocado, pickled onions, tofu, sweet corn, asparagus, baby plum tomatoes, smoked bacon
ADD TO ANY SALAD
chicken 11 / shrimp 13 / salmon 15
STARTERS
$14
ROASTED BUTTERNUT SQUASH SOUP
Glazed apples, pomegranate, creme fraiche & vanilla oil
$20
AHI TUNA TARTAR
avocado purée, mango salsa, pickled cucumbers, wasabi vinaigrette
$19
PROSCIUTTO WRAPPED SEA SCALLOPS
cauliflower purée, red and green grape salad, warm porcini dressing
$18
LOBSTER TACOS
pineapple habanero salsa, lime fennel slaw, avocado, chili aioli, pickled onions
BURGERS & SANDWICHES
$21
GRILLED 8oz SIRLOIN BURGER
with fries or salad; add cheese, bacon 2.00/ea avocado 5.00
$19
OREGANO ROASTED CHICKEN SANDWICH
avocado, tomato, pancetta, cucumber yogurt, grilled bread, with fries or salad
$22
TRUFFLED MUSHROOM ASPARAGUS TURKEY BURGER
porcini aioli, with fries or salad; add cheese, bacon 2.00/ea avocado 5.00
SIDES
$13
Fries With Gorgonzola Fondue
$13
Parmesan Roasted Cauliflower With Toasted Garlic
$13
Truffle Mac And Cheese Tart
$13
Grilled Asparagus
$13
Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Caramelized Apples And Pancetta
$13
Extra Virgin Whipped Potatoes
$13
Sautéed Spinach With Garlic
$13
Truffle Whipped Potatoes
$9
Bacon
$6
Avocado
