Pies ‚Äòn’ Thighs

American / Southern

Brooklyn / Williamsburg


Get directions | 166 S 4th St., Brooklyn, NY 11211


Hours | Sunday 10am-12am, Monday 9am-12am, Tuesday 9am-12am, Wednesday 9am-12am, Thursday 9am-12am, Friday 9am-12am, Saturday 10am-12am


The new Pies ‚Äòn’ Thighs has opened its doors, and Williamsburg’s most influential hipsters are rejoicing. At least that seemed to be the case when we recently visited with Forking Tasty’s Jason Anello. As a matter of fact, I’m pretty sure we happened to be eating there while the hipster council of elders was holding an election or something. They apparently have a new leader, and he has a really sweet tank top on.
It does appear, though, that all those people in rolled up jean shorts know great home-style Southern cooking when they see it. This new, larger Pies ‚Äòn’ Thighs location is still turning out amazing fried chicken and comfort food classics that make you feel good inside. The chicken biscuit might be one of the most ridiculously unhealthy things we’ve ever seen on a plate, and it’s delicious. The place is cheap too – and cash only. No wonder it’s hipster central. Luckily, there’s an ATM out front spits out ten dollar bills, and we’re pretty sure we saw a Coinstar machine next to it. Bring a bag of change and your best suspenders.





Fried Chicken Box

Three pieces of fried chicken with a buttermilk biscuit & choice of side

Chicken Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, bacon, jack cheese, ranch, avocado, LTO, mayo on a toasted bun, with salad or fries

Fried Catfish Box

Cornmeal-fried catfish with cornbread, tartar sauce, pickles. Choice of side

Fried Catfish Sandwich

Catfish, lettuce, slaw, tartar, pickles, hot sauce, mayo on a bun, with salad or fries

Insane Burger W/Fries

Grass-fed burger with a fried egg, bacon, cheese, LTO, pickles, mayo on a toasted bun, with fries

Hamburger W/Fries

Grass-fed burger w/ LTO, pickles, and mayo, served with fries

Grilled Cheese W/Fries

American cheese on buttery toasted homemade anadama bread served with fries

Big Salad

Fresh beets, carrots, avocado, radish, sprouts, spicy black-eyed peas, and egg on a bed of iceberg with a side of anadama toast choice of dressing: cilantro-lime vinaigrette or buttermilk ranch

Chicken Biscuit

Crispy chicken cutlet on a buttermilk biscuit slathered in hot sauce and honey butter

Chicken & Waffles

Two pieces of fried chicken and two buckwheat waffles topped with cinnamon butter & baked apples

Biscuits & Gravy

Buttermilk biscuit smothered in house-made sausage gravy

Fish & Grits

Cornmeal-fried catfish, two eggs and a side of cheese grits

Egg Breakfast

Two eggs, buttermilk biscuit with jam and choice of homefries, grits or salad

Rob Evans on a Biscuit

Buttermilk biscuit w/ two scrambled eggs, cheese, smothered in sausage gravy

Hippie Banjo

Egg, cheddar, avocado, tomato, sprouts & mayo on anadama


Egg & cheese on a biscuit.

Add bacon or sausage

Biscuit W/Jelly & Cream Cheese

Buttermilk biscuit with cream cheese and choice of hot pepper or sour cherry jelly


Three sides and choice of biscuit or cornbread

Mac ‘N’ Cheese

Smoked Pork Collards

Burnt End Baked Beans

Hush Puppies

with tartar & lemon

Cole Slaw

French Fries

Spicy Black Eyed Pea Salad

Iceberg Salad


Green Salad

Apple Pie

Banana Cream Pie

Bourbon Pecan Pie

Sour Cherry Pear Pie